← All Issues Subscribe Free
News and insights for independent restaurant owners

The Restaurant Brief

This Week
Cheaper gas puts a few dollars back in your guests' pockets, but it doesn't fix a maxed-out credit card or a paycheck that hasn't kept up with the last three years of prices. The guests who are pulling back aren't doing it because they drove here and felt the pain at the pump. They're doing it because the cushion is gone. If your traffic is soft, the answer is not to wait for relief that isn't coming. The answer is to give your core guest a reason to choose you over staying home.
Your beverage program is one of the few places on your P&L where an independent can actually close the gap with a chain without spending a fortune. An in-house cocktail or specialty drink program, built around house-made syrups, batched formats, or a tight curated list, can push beverage margins north of 70% and give your guests something they can't get at the place down the street. If you're still pouring the same well spirits with a standard pour cost and calling it a bar program, you're leaving the best margin on your menu sitting untouched.
Mid-year traffic numbers are telling you the same thing your instincts already are: people are being choosy, and fewer of them are walking in. The operators who are holding traffic right now are winning on one of two things, a clear value story or a clear reason-to-come-back story. If you can't say in one sentence why someone should pick your place over cooking at home tonight, that's the problem worth solving before you touch anything else.
If you've been thinking about selling, buying, or taking on a partner, the landscape has changed and lenders are not feeling generous. Deals that got done on a handshake and a concept two years ago now need clean books, documented cash flow, and a P&L that can hold up to real scrutiny. That's actually good news if your house is in order, because the buyer or seller across the table from you may not be ready for that conversation and you will be. ---
Know Your Numbers

Contribution margin per cover Most operators watch food cost percentage, which tells you how efficiently you're buying and portioning. But contribution margin per cover tells you how many real dollars each guest leaves behind after food cost. It's what you actually have to pay your staff, your rent, and yourself. Take your net food sales for a shift or a week, subtract your food cost dollars, and divide by the number of covers. If that number is under $12 to $14 in a casual full-service environment, your menu is not doing enough work even if your food cost percentage looks clean on paper. In a traffic-soft environment where you may be seating fewer covers than last year, each guest matters more than ever. A table of four either funds your week or it doesn't. Pull your numbers from the last 30 days and compare them to the same period last year. If the number dropped and your food cost percentage stayed the same, you've got a menu mix problem. Your guests are moving toward lower-priced items and your food cost is holding because those items are also cheaper to make. The fix is usually a menu structure issue, not a cost issue. This week: run contribution margin per cover for your last full week and compare it to 90 days ago. If it's trending down, look at what your top five selling items are now versus then. The shift in what's selling will tell you exactly what you're dealing with. ---

The Brief
This week's takeaway
Pull your five best-margin items and your five highest-selling items this week. If those two lists don't overlap at all, your menu is working against you and that's the first thing to fix.

Get the Restaurant Brief in your inbox every Thursday. Free.

Subscribe Now